Friday, 26 September 2008

Who needs the EU to make blogging illegal?

The Italians are already leading the way:

Italian bloggers are up in arms at a court ruling early this year that suggests almost all Italian blogs are illegal. This month, a senior Italian politician went one step further, warning that most web activity is likely to be against the law.

The story begins back in May, when a judge in Modica (in Sicily) found local historian and author Carlo Ruta guilty of the crime of "stampa clandestina" – or publishing a "clandestine" newspaper – in respect of his blog. The judge ruled that since the blog had a headline, that made it an online newspaper, and brought it within the law’s remit.

The penalties for this crime are not onerous: A fine of 250 Euros or a prison sentence of up to two years. Carlo Ruta was fined and ordered to take down his site, which has now been replaced by a blank page, headed "Site under construction", and a link directing surfers to his new site. Hardly serious stuff – except that he now has a criminal record, and his original site has disappeared.

The offence has its origins in 1948, when in apparent contradiction of Article 21 of the Italian Constitution guaranteeing the right to free expression, a law was passed requiring publishers to register officially before setting up a new publication. The intention, in the immediate aftermath of Fascism, may have been to regulate partisan and extremist publications. The effect was to introduce into Italian society a highly centrist and bureaucratic approach to freedom of the Press.

A further twist to this tale took place in 2001, with the realisation that existing laws were inadequate to deal with the internet. Instead of liberalising, the Italian Government sought to bring the internet into the same framework as traditional print media. Law 62, passed in March 2001, introduces the concept of "stampa clandestina" to the internet.

Truly the inmates, etc.


Mark Wadsworth said...

Yup. And when you have a media this powerful, you end up with a media tycoon as Prime Minister ... and so on.

Guthrum said...

Jesus H Christ Don't tell the Lord Protector, he will reintroduce the Stamp Acts

Curly said...

I am not expecting the latest EU backdown to be the end of the matter, these continental chaps and chapesses worry me greatly.

JuliaM said...

"I am not expecting the latest EU backdown to be the end of the matter..."

Sound expectations. They certainly don't consider a refurendum should be the end of a matter, after all...

Anonymous said...

Don't just complain. Act!

Vote YES to Free Europe at